Well, at least now we know.
John Maine, your time is now. You're only stepping in for one of the most-dominant pitchers of his era, the man whose arrival was a Piazzaesque sign that the Mets mattered again, one of the figures so vital to his sport that you say his first name and everybody knows who you mean. So no pressure or anything.
Our commentors have supplied the stats: We were 11-12 in Pedro starts this year, as an electric April gave way to a frustrating May and then a mostly doleful rest of the season. Yes, Pedro pitched his guts out in May with nary a W to show for it, but the mere fact that you have to dig deep into the stats to defend him tells the story -- as many predicted, this was the year that the body (helped along by the floors of the Marlins' vile, OSHA-violation-encrusted, Soilmaster-infested stadium) thoroughly betrayed the artist that is Pedro J. Martinez, creating a deficit that even his legendary brains, grit and guile couldn't make up.
Summing up Pedro through cold empty stats has always been a fool's errand -- if there's ever been a pitcher whose intangibles and unquantifiables must be spoken of, it's him. Which is one of the reasons this isn't another invitation to cannonball into the East River. Lead the Mets? He already has. We'll never know how many tete-a-tetes on the dugout bench helped the rest of the staff, or how many clubhouse or team-bus antics helped the young players realize they belonged. Here's devoutly hoping he'll drag his protective boot to Shea next week and then to St. Louis or Los Angeles or San Diego or Houston and then (we even more devoutly hope) to destinations unknown, so that wise counsel can be given or a joke cracked when it really matters to some member of the 2006 postseason squad. 26th man, sixth starter, second pitching coach -- as long as I see him there, I'll feel better about things. He taught a lot of his current teammates the things they needed to learn to come this far. Those lessons won't evaporate along with his roster spot.
And, honestly, it's a relief to have a little clarity. There's no arguing with a torn tendon. Anything less definitive, and Pedro would have tried -- which is in no way a knock on him, but a tribute to his lionhearted self. He would have tried, and it wouldn't have worked -- that did-it-with-mirrors ride to the rescue in Cleveland was seven years and a lot of miles ago. I think we all sensed last night that he had no magic left in the 2006 hat, even if we were reluctant to admit it. I'm not sure Pedro would have admitted it -- you don't climb to the pinnacle of sports from where Pedro started without superhuman confidence in your own abilities, without a certainty that you're invulnerable. Unfortunately, there's no off switch -- the ineffable, enviable mix of belief and defiance is what makes an athlete the first to believe, but it's the same thing that makes him or her the last to know.
And that would have left Willie and Omar and the Jacket with a terrible dilemma, one that would have had us fretting and fighting and moaning: Should Pedro start Game 4? Pitch in relief? It's a later round, can he give it a go? Now, it's academic. The MRI has spoken, the verdict is in, and it's time to get on with it.
Oh yes, the game: It was like a documentary about a World War I battle, wasn't it? Grim and sloppy and endless, with the sole levity provided by the loopy announcers and David Wright's hasty retreat (with a mouthed "Wow!") as Country Joe West instructed Brian McCann to take his opinions about the strike zone to the shower.
Anyway, we won. We even hit a little. It doesn't feel like the relief we'd hoped for, not with this news to absorb, but perhaps when we get to Washington we'll win a couple more and hit a bunch more, and remember that, hey, we really are going to the postseason. Now, please tell me we're going there with Pedro, that he'll brandish his toy bat and flash his elfin grin and whisper a word or two. I wish we could have more from him than that. We all do. But if we can bring his intangibles and unquantifiables, let's remember they're Hall of Fameworthy too.
(By the way, did anybody else hide behind the couch when El Duque reached for that ball with his bare hand? Between that, Pedro and Reyes's kamikaze slide I felt vaguely like throwing up all night.)
(Oh yeah -- if you want a Faith and Fear shirt, holler.)
The blog for Mets fans
who like to read Search
GET THE BOOK!
Faith and Fear in Flushing: An Intense Personal History by Greg Prince (foreword by Jason Fry), is available now via Amazon, Barnes & Noble and other online booksellers. Recent Entries
This Month
Month Archive
About Us
Faith and Fear in Flushing made its debut on Feb. 16, 2005, the brainchild of two longtime friends and lifelong Met fans.
Greg Prince discovered the Mets when he was 6, during the magical summer of 1969. He is a Long Island-based writer, editor and communications consultant. Contact him here. Jason Fry is a Brooklyn writer whose first memories include his mom leaping up and down cheering for Rusty Staub. Check out his other writing here. Like a Word With Us?
To comment on the blog, register here. Or you can email us at faithandfear@gmail.com
Use Facebook? Come check out our page, or drop by the personal pages for Greg and Jason. Faith and Fear Shirts
The Faith and Fear in Flushing "numbers" shirt has been seen from Verona, N.J., to Venice. You can get yours right here -- price about as cheap as we can make it. Blog Park @ FAFIF Yards
Dream Seats (Sit Back and Enjoy)
Metphistopheles MetsBlog Mets Guy in Michigan Metstradamus Mets Walkoffs Mike's Mets Field Level (Close to the Action) Always Amazin' Amazin' Avenue BlueAndOrange.net Eddie Kranepool Society Hot Foot MetsGeek The Mets Police Shea Nation Loge (Unique Perspective) The Ballclub Blastings Thrilledge Brooklyn Met Fan CitiBlog Dana Brand Mets Fan Blog Ed in Westchester Loge 13 The Metropolitans Mets Are Better Than Sex Mets Grrl Met Silverman My Summer Family No No Hitters Optimistic Mets Fan Serval Zippers Take the 7 Train Toasty Joe's Yankees 2000 Curse Auxiliary Press Box Daily News: Surfing the Mets John Delcos' NY Mets Report Improve Conditions (Tim Marchman) Journal News: The LoHud Mets Blog Newsday: On the Mets Beat Post: Mets Chat The Record: Amazin' Stories Star-Ledger: On the Mets Times: Bats (Mets Posts) WFAN: Ed Coleman Mezzanine (Great Distance) 213 Miles From Shea Archie Bunker's Army Chicago Mets Fan Cockeyed Optimist Let's Go Mets Lone Star Mets Mets Fan in Chicago Orange & Blue Harbor Southern Mets Transplanted Mets Fan Upstate Mets Fan Upper Deck (What a Crowd!) 24 Hours From Suicide Beautiful Addition to Your Baseball Library Betty's No Good Big Cat Church of the Fonz Coppola Sisters Crossbow Project Flushing Fussing Global NY Mets Fan Blog Go Mets Die Braves Gotta Believers Hopeless Mets Fan It's Mets for Me Ketchup on Your Ice Cream Let's Go Mets Tumblr Matt Himelfarb Met Baseball Mets Bullpen Mets Fans Forever Mets Fever Mets Heads Metsie Mets Lifer Mets Merized Online Mets Mole Mets Monkeys Mets Prospect Hub Mets Prospects Mets Prospectus The Metwork Mets Today Misery Loves Company Mostly Mets Mr. Flushing Mr. Metzyzptlk Never Forget '69 NY Met Fan Oliver & I Perfect Pitch Pick Me Up Some Mets Priced Out of the Citi Rational Mets Musings The 'Ropolitans Seven Train to Shea Ventilate Warning Track Power What Would Keith Hernandez Do? The Wright Stuff Ya Gotta Believe You Can't Script Baseball Zisk Online Mets Extra
You Could Look It Up
Baseball Almanac: Mets The Baseball Cube Baseball Library Baseball Prospectus Baseball Reference: Mets Cool Standings Cot's Baseball Contracts ESPN: Players ESPN: Scores Hall of Fame Metaforian Mets by the Numbers Retrosheet Salary vs. Performance Ultimate Mets Database The Youth of America Buffalo Bisons Binghamton Mets St. Lucie Mets Savannah Sand Gnats Brooklyn Cyclones Kingsport Mets The Braintrust Daily News The Journal News Newsday New York Post The Record (N.J.) The Star-Ledger New York Times Road Apples Atlanta Journal-Constitution Miami Herald Philly.com Washington Post Press Notes Ballhype ESPN Clubhouse: Mets ESPN Local MLB Press Pass Sports Illustrated: Mets Sports Illustrated Vault SportsSpyder Yahoo Mets Grant's Tombs Polo Grounds Shea Stadium CitiField (2009) Out of Town Scoreboard Ballparks, Arenas & Stadiums Ballparks of Baseball Ballpark Tour Baseball Pilgrimages Clem's Ballpark Diagrams Digital Ballparks Frank's Ballparks Jay Buckley Baseball Tours Mike McCann's Engaging Images Stadium Page Frequency Bob Murphy CW 11 Gary, Keith & Ron MLB Extra Innings Neil Best's Watchdog NY Baseball Digest Radio Roadtrip SNY WFAN XM Radio YouTube: JPhilips41 The Picnic Area 19th Century Mets 100 Greatest NY Days Armchair GM Bad Mets Bugs and Cranks Carl's Mets Page CBS Sportsline: Mets Centerfield Maz Crosstown Rivals DGW Photo Blog Eephus Pitch Flushing University Forgotten New York Gotham Baseball Hot Dog Vending at Shea Howard Megdal I Heart Mets Inside Pitch Jackie Robinson Foundation Knuckleball From Hell Long Island Ducks Mathematically Alive Meet the Matts Met Camp Met Fan Book Mets Fan Club Mets Images Mets Pulse Mets Short Mets Tube Mets Zone New York Mets Hall of Records NY Mets Report NY Sports Day NY Sports Dog NY SportSpace A Piece of Shea Productive Outs & Cracker Jack Pro Sports Daily: Mets Rumors A Quest for Keith Record Online SABR NYC Save the Apple SportSnipe Steve's Mets Photos TNYM True Fans Bleed Blue & Orange Very Unofficial Mets Site Extreme Baseball At Home Plate Baseball Analysts Baseball Bookshelf Baseball Card Blog Baseball Crank Baseball Fever Baseball Limo Baseball Talmud Baseball Think Factory Baseball Toaster Blogging Baseball Bobby V's Way Cardboard Gods Cardboard Junkie The Dead Ball Era The Dugout Dugout Central Excruciating Baseball Lists Hardball Times Israel Baseball League Japan Baseball Daily Jewish Major Leaguers Negro Leagues Baseball Museum Quality At-Bats SABR Sports Collectors Daily Squeeze Play Cards Stats on the Back Streetplay Super '70s Baseball Cards Topps Baseball Card Blog United States of Baseball USA Today Write On Sports Yard Work Zack Hample Multipurpose Stadium American Legends Blooming Ideas Brooklyn Mutt Can't Stop the Bleeding The Daily Fix Dan Shanoff Deadspin Gelf Magazine Getting Paid to Watch Get Untracked Gil Meche Experience Hot Stove New York The Jestaplero Joe Posnanski Ladies... Legend of Cecilio Guante Mike's Neighborhood Riding With Rickey Straight Flushing Uni Watch Uni Watch Blog The Rotunda Amazinz Crane Pool Forum Grand Slam Single Happy Recap Board Mets Refugees The Mofo Talk Baseball Everybody's Comin' Down Mets: Official Site The 7 Train LIRR FAFIF Says...
Very Hot Stove
Met Hell First Circle Second Circle Second Second Circle Fourth Circle Fifth Circle Aw Heck Sixth Circle Seventh Circle Eighth Circle Ninth Circle Redemption Look Who's No. 100-1 Criteria 100-91 90-81 80-71 70-61 60-51 50-41 40-31 30-21 20-11 10-1 * Years to Remember 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 Moments of Silence Hunter S. Thompson Bernie The Cat Nate Fisher Donn Clendenon John Spencer Lou Rawls Tom Belcher Five Years Later Cory Lidle Highlight Films Greatest Hits of 1986 Winter League 2005-2006 The 2005 Faith and Fear Yearbook |
Comments
Re: Clarity
For all who had penciled Pedro onto your postseason rosters -- and if you assumed Willie would take 11 pitchers -- look at it this way: 96% of the Mets and 91% of the Mets' pitchers will still be there.
I'll take those odds. I'll also take Dave Williams to the dance if it's my call. Oliver Perez is tempting, but wild. Roberto Hernandez is not, but probable. I really liked what Williams did in his several Pedro fill-in starts. We can't be the only team in the world that has trouble with crafty lefties. But that's window dressing for the moment. Trachsel or Maine? Consider them your Reese's Peanut Butter Cup. You got experienced guy in my hard thrower! You got hard thrower in my experienced guy! Hey, this isn't bad! We hope. (And if you can't have Pedro, how about a nice shirt?) Re: Re: Clarity
I thought the same thing tonight: What did Dave Williams do wrong?
Besides, we all know Oliver Perez will get starts in 2007's postseason. (Boy, I put all the bravado I could into that and it just doesn't work. I'd never make it as a Yankee fan.) Re: Re: Clarity
by
Laurie
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 10:00 AM EDT | Permanent Link
It's not so much that I'm thinking "oh my God, what will we do now, without Pedro?" because yes, we've been winning most of the year without him. For me it's more "our pitching has been so sketchy... I was really hoping to get Pedro back so it would be less so." I just wanted to exhale, basically.
I'm worried as ****. What I've seen in Atlanta this week has scared the living daylights out of me. We keep moving further down the list of the best teams in baseball. The Twins--who in June seemed destined to finish third in their own division--now have a better record than us. Ouch. Let's get it together, guys. Fast. This was supposed to be Our Year... don't tank on us now! Re: Clarity
This Nats-Phillies game is great: a West Coast start in Washington, DC.
Of note: The Nat announcers, both with frayed Mets ties (forgotten Channel 9 alum Bob Carpenter, '85 pinch-hitter Tom Paciorek), are burying us. We don't have good starting pitching. The West teams are hot. Even St. Louis could do it. Good. I've had enough of being the favorite. I've got a stack of magazines from the past week: SI, ESPN, New York, Time (Time, for cripes' sake!) declaring us, at last, the flavor of the month. I think they were all written in July. Spit like that makes me nervous. All due respect to the spirit of '86, this is more like it. Hey National League, get comfortable. Get real comfortable. As for the Phillies, their fans at RFK (there aren't many of either kind) were just chanting for Jimmy Rollins, "Jay-Ro! Jay-Ro Jay-Ro Jay-Ro!" Hey morons, go rip off your own soccer song. Re: Re: Clarity
Re "Jay-Ro": The Philadelphia papers say the fans used to sing that tune for T.O., which I think would make it a fair borrow. (Holy Sandman!)
Not to be all fair and stuff. Re: Clarity
Seriously, dude, get me to a playoff game right now. I'm fucking ready.
Re: Re: Clarity
by
CharlieH
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 12:55 PM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
I'm in for games 1 & 2 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Re: Clarity
by
KingmanFan
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 09:58 AM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
The team site reports that the Mets are now considering carrying three catchers, and only five OFers with Michael Tucker getting the nod over Lasto. I can understand carrying DeFelice, I guess, so you can use Castro to pinch hit, but I was kinda pulling for Milledge. I had visions of him coming up big in a surprise start, or late in a game. Tucker, I dunno, I see him as nothing more than did-not-play, or grounding out for Heileman in the 8th. And every time I see DeFelice's mug I can only think of the dumbest managerial move Willie ever made, 'bout a year ago.
The hopeless romantic in me was hoping that Pedro would get DLed, opening a spot on the roster for a certain veteran infielder who could fill in vs lefties and provide backup insurance at all IF spots. Re: Re: Clarity
Alas, they would have to open a spot on the 40 man to add the (not so)mysterious player you refer to. They would have to DL Pedro for 60. That and the fact the player did little this year adds up to no move.
To all Milledge, they would have to DL someone as well, but not make room on the 40. The Mets play by the book, so Anderson Hernandez will not come down with a mysterious back injury. Yet. Re: Re: Re: Clarity
by
NostraDennis
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 11:42 AM EDT | Permanent Link
But if he did, could we call it an "A-Hern-ia"?
Sorry. Sorry. Re: Re: Re: Clarity
by
KingmanFan
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 12:46 PM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
That was precisely my thinking - if you DL Pedro, does that open a spot on the 40-man? And if it requires a 60-day stint, does that clock run during the offseason?
Eh, it's all for naught... Omar has shown no such inclination toward sentimentality, and you can't really argue Fonzie's inclusion on merit (though I dream that he would magically turn the clock back six years because it's October). Re: Re: Clarity
by
Laurie
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 12:17 PM EDT | Permanent Link
The hopeless romantic in me was hoping that Pedro would get DLed, opening a spot on the roster for a certain veteran infielder who could fill in vs lefties and provide backup insurance at all IF spots.
OK, now I'm going to cry... :-( Re: Clarity
by
Anonymous
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 11:45 AM EDT | Permanent Link
Tears on my Pedro... pain in my heart... caused by youuuuuuuuuuu... Re: Clarity
by
albertsonmets
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 12:16 PM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
As your apt analogy to the '02 Angels and a cheesy sports marketing campaign have made clear, you can't script the postseason. You don't know what heroes will emerge and what thrills lie in store (see Mets, '99). As your partner said, bring it on.
And one minor nitpick: one needn't limit oneself to vague discussions of intangibles and grit when defining the greatness of Pedro. Surely, these elements are part of the mystique but the stats also bear witness to the fact that he is one of the best ever. Re: Re: Clarity
Nitpick most definitely acknowledge. I done wrote that crappity.
Subconsciously, I probably skipped the stats because a) Pedro the Met has been, on balance, more about the intangibles; and b) I can barely add. Re: Re: Re: Clarity
by
albertsonmets
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 01:08 PM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
And you actually made no reference to the Angels, '02 or otherwise. I read that somewhere else and this stuff can run together in the old brain sometimes.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Clarity
by
JerseyJack
on Fri 29 Sep 2006 08:56 PM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
When was the last time a team won in the mid- 90s with such an iffy starting rotation ??.....................
|

